Was the Urban Decay eye pencil a hit or a miss? Read our review to find out

When it comes to eyeliner, I tend to stick to the neutrals like charcoal gray or chocolate brown. So when I had the opportunity to try one of Urban Decay's 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencils, which come in an array of fun shades, I was excited. I lined my lids with Sabbath, which is a matte navy blue. I was pleased with how easy it was to create a straight line with the pencil, and loved how the blue hue complimented my eyes and fair skin.

The pencil touts itself as being waterproof, and I can confidently say that it lives up to the claim: The eyeliner stayed put even after I sobbed my way through the one hour and fifteen minute series finale of my favorite television show, "The Office." The only drawback is that it smudges slightly underneath my lower lash line after initial application, but it's nothing a cotton swab can't fix. Plus, the Glide-On Eye Pencil is only $19 (find them at UrbanDecay.com), so it won't break the bank. I'm already looking forward to checking out the other colors.

-Heather Weekley, @heather_weekley