Wedding of the Week: Natalie and Joshua McPheron

From friends to happily ever after

Emma Frankart Henterly
Columbus Monthly
Natalie and Joshua McPheron at their Aug. 15, 2020.

Aug. 15, 2020 | Joshua and Natalie (Herning) McPheron know firsthand that strong friendship and religious faith are two solid foundations upon which to build a relationship: The pair met during a freshman scholarship program at Bowling Green State University, but deepened their friendship during a mission trip and subsequent internship at their campus church. By the end of their sophomore year, the then-best friends decided to elevate their relationship to the next level. 

The day of their wedding, Natalie says one of her favorite memories will always be seeing Josh at the end of the aisle—and his emotional reaction to seeing her. (Looking at the photos, who can blame her? We’re smitten ourselves.) While the couple had skipped a first look, they did do a “first touch,” wherein the pair held hands while separated by a corner of a building. “It was so comforting and sweet to hold his hand and pray with him before our wedding,” Natalie says. 

At the reception, the newlyweds spread the love: They gave one of their bridesmaids and her husband their very own first dance as well, after their May wedding and reception had to be canceled due to COVID. 

“It really was the most perfect day,” Natalie says. “Our vendors were amazing, and the Farm at Harvest Hills staff were the most kind and accommodating people. … [They] worked so hard to keep everything safe.”  


Photographer: Captured Photography 

Ceremony and reception: The Farm at Harvest Hills 

Catering: PC Events Catering 

Cake: Fresh Start Café and Bakery 

Florist: Alex “Tyler” Basile of Connells Maple Lee Flower & Gifts 

Stationery: and DIY 

Music: Buckeye Entertainment 

Videographer: Josh Zuck Videography 

Rehearsal dinner: The Farm at Harvest Hills 

Newlyweds’ accommodations: Landoll’s Mohican Castle 

Bride’s look: L’Amour Calla Blanche gown from Wendy’s Bridal, veil purchased on Facebook Marketplace, Sun + Stone shoes from Macy’s, grandmother’s necklace, jewelry from Amazon and Francesca’s, hair by Sydney Poehler of 614 Beauty, makeup by Taelor Ammon 

Groom’s look: Suit and accessories from Men’s Wearhouse  

Engagement ring: C Sterling Jewelers (Perrysburg) 

Wedding bands: Ashcroft & Oak Jewelers 

Bridesmaid gowns: David’s Bridal 

Groomsmen suits: Men’s Wearhouse 

Flower girl’s dress: JCPenney 

Ring bearer’s suit: Kohl’s