STEAK 'N SHAKE
multiple locations, steaknshake.com
Folks around here love their Steak 'n Shake milkshakes. Made with real milk and ice cream, they were the clear winner for the third year in a row. Whether you go for the classic hand-dipped, the two-toned side-by-side or one of their decadent specialties, they set the standard for 'shakes.
RUNNERS-UP: Graeter's, Dairy Queen
HONORABLE MENTION: Chick-fil-A, Culver's